So the book of mormon peoples would not have had the faintest idea of what a bible was. Adieu is simply one english word among many in the book of mormon translation. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. The book of mormon definition of the book of mormon by. He is best known for his lengthy prayer while hunting in the wilderness, wherein he first asks for personal forgiveness, then for gods blessings upon the nephites, then his blessings upon the lamanites, then that a record of the nephites will be preserved and brought into the lamantes at some future day should. Because god flashed it onto joseph smiths magic8ball rockinahat the same way that god flashed the kjv deuteroisaiah onto smiths magic rock. Jacob 7 1 and now it came to pass after some years had passed away, there came a man among the people of nephi, whose. Reynolds and sjodahl, commentary on the book of mormon, vol. Read my words adieu according to angela crowell, jacob closes his book with a farewell sentence which ends with the word adieu. So, whether it is adieu or constraineth or abomination, they are modern translations of ancient words. This may be the single most important concept for the jews to understand. We dont know much of the actual mechanics of the translation process. Adieu in the book of mormon book of mormon translation.
There are multitudes of problems withe the book of mormon, not the least of which is the fact that much of the later official doctrine of the church contradicts muc. Religious studies center, brigham young university, 1990, 5572. Some claim that because adieu is french, it shows that joseph smith composed the book of mormon, and not an ancient author. Spirit speaks to all of us and we all know the truth deep down jacob 4. Because it was a revelation from god to joseph smith. Mar 06, 2015 the book of mormon, on the other hand, uses the word priest 105 times and the word elder in an ecclesiastical sense only 9 times. Joseph obviously felt it a fitting equivalent to jacobs farewell in reformed egyptian. The fifth chapter in the book of jacob or jacob 5 is the longest single chapter in the book of mormon at 77 verses.
Some of them make valid points and are difficult to resolve. Why, for example, is the word book, which comes from old english and was not known in old testament times, found in the old testament. The 1828 edition of websters american dictionary of the english language defines adieu as a farewell, or commendation to the care of god. This allegory tells the story of the lords dealings with the house of israel.
Adieu in the book of mormon philosophies of men mingled. Nov 21, 2018 the book of mormon is claimed to be the most correct book on earth and the keystone of the church of jesus christ of latterday saints. How do you figure this question is anti anything, it is a question and as such no inference is implied. The book of mormon, on the other hand, uses the word priest 105 times and the word elder in an ecclesiastical sense only 9 times. Gardner earned a masters degree in anthropology and mesoamerican ethnohistory from the state university of new york at albany. If the book of mormon was translated from egyptian,how did a.
As you mention, the french language did not start to be developed until after 600 b. Why are the words adieu, bible, and baptize in the book of. The various forms of the word baptize are found 145. Quizlet flashcards, activities and games help you improve your grades. Perhaps it would help to divide it into the following sections, which describe periods of the worlds history. Some critics of the book of mormon try to claim it as a fraud because one verse contains the french word, adieu. Adieu implies farewell until we meet with god, a fitting finale to jacobs testimony and writing. Arent mormons supposed go get married on alien planets or something. It was in common use among latterday saints and others in josephs era. Some antilds critics of the book of mormon have raised the question as to how jacob could possibly have used such a word as adieu when this word clearly comes from the french language, which was not developed until hundreds of years after the time of jacob. Adieu in the book of mormon philosophies of men mingled with.
While i dont believe in the book of mormon, i do believe in grammar. And i, jacob, saw that i must soon go down to my grave. Enos is the third author in the book of mormon after nephi 1 and jacob. If the book of mormon was translated from egyptian,how did a french word get in it. Maxwell institute for religious scholarship and nibley llc. In translating the book of mormon, joseph smith had to find words that conveyed the meaning of the reformed egyptian words. Why are the words adieu, bible, and baptize in the book of mormon. This is why words not known in book of mormon times are found in the translated text. The word adieu was in common use in english in joseph smiths era. Supporters of the book of mormon argue that the text is a translation into modern english, so the use of a french word is not amiss. Although adieu is now and was in joseph smiths day more or less synonymous with farewell, it originally meant something more like i commend you to god.
The choice of words came through the manner of the language of joseph smith, so that we might have understanding. Well, were letting the book speak for itself and here it is showing joseph smith lying to the people once again. It is the word by which a reason is introduced of something before advanced websters 1828 dictionary. The answer to both questions is simply that the book of mormon and the king james version of the bible are translations from ancient languages through the function of translators, who diligently endeavored to convey the intended meaning of the original writers. Only for those folks who are programmed to believe such would actually say that. Joseph smith likely chose to use the word adieu because it concisely conveyed a sense of finality. Analytical and contextual commentary on the book of mormon and the gift and power. The translator has the obligation of conveying the sense or meaning of the pictographic depiction. Another testament of jesus christ more important than. Cheryl brown, i speak somewhat concerning that which i have written, in the book of mormon.
Meaning of every knee shall bow and tongue confess. Jun 15, 2008 how do you figure this question is anti anything, it is a question and as such no inference is implied. The come follow me manual states jacob 5 is a long chapter the longest in the book of mormon. A question has arisen in the minds of some readers of the book of mormon as to why this common french word adopted by english speakers was used. First, the terms barley and wheat, as used in the book of mormon, may refer to certain other new world crop plants that were given old world designations. The book of mormon is a translation of an ancient text into a modern language, and the word that best fit the ending jacob used some parting expression commending his readers to god was translated as adieu to god, an expression that is used and widely understood in the english speaking world. There was no greek or latin upon the plates from which i, through the grace of god, translated the book of mormon let the language of that book speak for itself. One of the sacred books of the mormon church, published in 1830 by joseph smith and considered by mormons to be a historic record of the migration of. Jacob chapter 5 in the book of mormon is a fairly long and complex one.
The condescension of god is explained using a hebrew phrase for god will lower himself to mortal life. However, the fact that jacob ends his book with the french word adieu, has actually become another evidence for the truthfulness of the book of mormon. Feb 10, 2008 14 but i, jacob, shall not hereafter distinguish them by these names, but i shall call them lamanites that seek to destroy the people of nephi, and those who are friendly to nephi i shall call. Verses 314 the scattering of israel before the time of christ. Strange words and names in the book of mormon fairmormon. Anachronisms in the book of mormon religious studies center. Book of mormon greek and latin word chart life after. Christianity in the prechristian book of mormon meridian.
Book of mormon greek and latin word chart life after ministry. Since the nephites did not speak french which didnt even exist until centuries later, how can this be justified. Im new here, so this has probably been way hashed over, but ive been studying latin, some greek, and a little linguistics this semester in school, and came across something interesting. For example, the spanish called the fruit of the prickly pear cactus a fig. The golden plates comic series, originally a book of mormon adaptation project started by michael allred in the early 2000s, was recently updated and made reavailable online at lds ideas. Joseph smith likely chose to use the word adieu because it. Elder joseph fielding smith said, the parable of zenos, recorded by jacob in chapter five of his book, is one of the greatest parables ever recorded. Jacob 5 is the longest chapter in the book of mormon 77 verses and consists in its entirety of the allegory of the olive trees taught by the prophet zenos. Does anyone know why the french word adieu was added to the. Adieu was already common in english language and joseph smith must have thought that adieu more accurately translated jacob s farewell. According to richardson, richardson and bentley, the closing word in the book of jacob adieu jacob 7. It is important to understand that the next four books, jacob, enos, jarom, and onmi, are all written upon the small plates that nephi made thirty years after leaving jerusalem 2 ne 5. Why is the word adieu attributed to the book of mormon. It is commonplace for students of the geography of book of mormon events to.
The book of mormon is claimed to be the most correct book on earth and the keystone of the church of jesus christ of latterday saints. Joseph used the terms in his vocabulary to convey the intended meaning of the book of mormon. He has presented papers at fairmormon conferences and published in the farms. Such critics evidently overlook the fact that the book of mormon is translation. The word adieu was in common usage in new england at the time, and it meant towards god, sort of like god be with you.
Nibleys commentary on the book of mormon is based on transcriptions from classes taught by hugh nibley, and is published with the permission of the neal a. Some have questioned the use of the french word adieu in jacob 7. Lesson learned from translating the book of mormon into. Not including questions 1, 37, 46, and 47 book of mormon midterm 2 john hilton iii study guide by glovemister includes 101 questions covering vocabulary, terms and more. This is allegedly a problem, an anachronism, because the word adieu was unknown to the ancient hebrew. Only for those folks who are programmed to believe such. How did the french word adieu get into the book of mormon. No, and neither did they speak english, and yet we have an english translation. Joseph smith translated the book of mormon into english. For example, some detractors have criticized the book of mormon for using the french word adieu jacob 7. This is a transliteration of the greek word epistolos, and would also have been unknown by the book of mormon people. He was a mighty man of god, and, apparently, next to nephi, the greatest and most devoted of all the sons of lehi.
This places the age of jacob between 4755 years of age at the time of this writing. There are multitudes of problems withe the book of mormon, not the least of which is the fact that much of the later official doctrine of the church contradicts much of the book of mormons doctrine. A dictionary of the book of mormon wikisource, the free. The increasing interest taken in the study of the book of mormon and in the history of the peoples whose origin, progress and destruction it narrates, encourages the author of this little work to think that this addition to the literature of the subject will not be like one born out of due time, but will be received as an acceptable aid to the study of its sacred pages. Many antis will have us believe that the addition of the word adieu in the book of mormon proves its falsity bec. Anyone who proclaims to understand the scriptures and the dealings of the lord with his people must understand this allegory. I speak somewhat concerning that which i have written. The book of mormon synonyms, the book of mormon pronunciation, the book of mormon translation, english dictionary definition of the book of mormon. The subject of the chapter is a story that the nephite prophet jacob relates, originally taught by zenos an old testament prophet mentioned only in the book of mormon.
Strictly speaking, no words in the book of mormon are jacob s words, or the words of any other prophet of that period. He spoke hebrew, and was acquainted with egyptian writing. The plates from which the book of mormon was translated were written in egyptian hieroglyphs, which is not even a phonetic language. There are many arguments against the book of mormon. That would be as true for the book of mormon as it is for any other text if the book of mormon claimed to be an ancient text, but it does not. Yesterdays anti mormon lit is todays gospel topic essays.
Adieu in the book of mormon and i, jacob, saw that i must soon go down to my grave. In this case, the book of mormon contradicts the kjv. An allegory uses symbolic representations to stand. The elder of the two sons born to lehi and sariah say between b.
Feb 21, 2012 some critics of the book of mormon try to claim it as a fraud because one verse contains the french word, adieu. How did the french word adieu get into the book of. Book of mormon midterm 2 john hilton iii flashcards quizlet. It does not explicitly name lehis wife sariah as the mother of jacob or joseph, but no other wife of lehi is ever mentioned. There are at least three problems with the adieu argument against the book of mormon. Jacob through words of mormon, to learn with joy, eds. If the book of mormon was translated from egyptian,how did. Adieu was probably the best equivalent of jacobs words of which joseph smith was aware. The word adieu is defined in a dictionary of joseph smiths day as a farewell. I have often heard critics of the book of mormon make a big stink over the word adieu in the book of mormon. Critics claim that because adieu is french, it shows that joseph smith composed the book of mormon, and not an ancient author. That older meaning actually makes more sense in the context, since jacob had already bid his readers farewell.
Adieu was probably the best equivalent of jacob s words of which joseph smith was aware. According to the book of mormon narrative, jacob was born in the wilderness during his father lehis journey from jerusalem to the promised land the americas sometime between 592 b. Elder joseph fielding smith said, the parable of zenos, recorded by jacob in chapter five of his book, is. This is allegedly a problem, an anachronism, because the word adieu was unknown to the ancient hebrew authors of the book. The french word adieu appears once in the book of mormon, in jacob 7. Many have assumed that anachronisms in the book of mormon should similarly prove that it must be false, and it is a modern text only posing as an ancient one. Andrew knaupp, who worked on revamping the series for digital format, found that immersing himelf in the project gave him unique insights regarding joseph smiths translation process. When the prophet received the concept or idea of a farewell at the conclusion of the portion of the record known as the book of jacob, he used an expression he felt would convey the message to our understanding. Jacobs usage of the word adieu in the book of mormon. Feb 16, 2008 jacob 7 jacob 7 1 and now it came to pass after some years had passed away, there came a man among the people of nephi, whose. We dont know much of the actual mechanics of the translation process, but what if at the end of that verse, joseph smith understood that translated meaning of what he read meant something to the effect of i commend you to god and felt that adieu was a proper fit since that is exactly what the word means. Though english is a germanic language, it adopted many french words, beginning. Read in that spirit, they fill the soul with a sweet and heavenly joy which only the spirit of god can produce.
And i make an end of my writing upon these plates, which writing has been small. Brandt, associate director, salt lake institute of religion. This relationship is of utmost importance because it is so commonly dealt with in other scriptures. According to richardson, richardson and bentley, the closing word in the book of jacob adieujacob 7. The enos problem in the book of mormon adventures in. Why is the word adieu attributed to the book of mormon writer jacob. Adieu is josephs translation of a concept expressed by jacob. Apr 02, 2009 if the book of mormon was translated from egyptian,how did a french word get in it. He is best known for his lengthy prayer while hunting in the wilderness, wherein he first asks for personal forgiveness, then for gods blessings upon the nephites, then his blessings upon the lamanites, then that a record of the nephites will be preserved and brought into the lamantes.
The book of mormon mentions jacob as the younger brother of nephi, and the elder of two sons born to lehi the younger son being joseph after lehis departure from jerusalem. Why is the french word adieu in the book of mormon. The original writers spoke neither english nor french. A dictionary of the book of mormonjacob wikisource, the. The same way that god flashed the kjv deuteroisaiah onto smiths magic rock. It is not sponsored or endorsed by either the maxwell institute or brigham young university, and. Jun 19, 2011 and i make an end of my writing upon these plates, which writing has been small. Strictly speaking, no words in the book of mormon are jacobs words, or the words of any other prophet of that period. Mar 19, 2009 enos is the third author in the book of mormon after nephi 1 and jacob. C jacob and his family eventually traveled to the americas via boat constructed by his brother, nephi. In the book of mormon, elder and priest are separate offices with an elder superior to a priest. Using the symbolism of the art world, one might even consider it the mona lisa masterpiece of the book of mormon. Joseph fielding smith had such praise for this passage that he said. Why is the french adieu in the book of mormon not proof that the book of mormon is false.
273 775 1277 369 1162 527 1594 856 1389 1151 1023 1529 597 986 665 1114 189 681 439 474 440 1260 1228 1448 796 1681 924 567 496 1265 1674 388 389 750 135 1285 414 99 843 742 376 1119 50 1304 1168 187 1219 1106 920